Aurora 4x

C# Aurora => Spoilers => Topic started by: SpaceMarine on February 23, 2021, 05:16:12 PM

Title: What is going on with swarm generation chance
Post by: SpaceMarine on February 23, 2021, 05:16:12 PM
This is a quick post just to tell steve that I believe something is borked with swarm because I have been playing since 1.0 and havent seen a single swarm that I have not spawned in myself, others have also said the same, either in recent versions theres been an issue behind the scenes thats borked them (which I doubt because we have atleast one confirmed case outside of steve) or the generation chance is very very small in which case I think it really needs to be higher as even invaders are more common than swarm.
Title: Re: What is going on with swarm generation chance
Post by: TheBawkHawk on February 23, 2021, 05:37:51 PM
I haven't seen the Swarm yet either. I've even tried using the SM create swarm button but that didn't appear to do anything. I took a peek in the DB, and found it was creating the swarm races just fine. The problem is that the generation wasn't giving the swarm any ships or units, so they didn't have any actual presence.
Title: Re: What is going on with swarm generation chance
Post by: nuclearslurpee on February 23, 2021, 05:50:22 PM
I've not seen any Swarms...ever, actually. Steve apparently ran into a bunch of them in his B5 campaign which I think was played with some of the initial 1.13 changes, so maybe the fix to Rakhas did something?
Title: Re: What is going on with swarm generation chance
Post by: TheTalkingMeowth on February 23, 2021, 06:25:45 PM
I ran into them in a 1.11 game. But not in 1.12.
Title: Re: What is going on with swarm generation chance
Post by: Froggiest1982 on February 23, 2021, 07:11:32 PM
I've highlighted this too on another post a month or so ago under suggestion as I wanted a PLAYER SLIDES for spoiler generation (it has been implemented only for NPR currently from 1.13), but a few users answered to me that they were common so I just kept playing.

I can confirm that as of today (more than 400 hours and roughly 4 different saves) that I've never met any swarm.

EDIT: I've looked always at the DBs and the swarm wasn't even there as a race listed.
Title: Re: What is going on with swarm generation chance
Post by: Droll on February 23, 2021, 08:08:25 PM
This is a quick post just to tell steve that I believe something is borked with swarm because I have been playing since 1.0 and havent seen a single swarm that I have not spawned in myself, others have also said the same, either in recent versions theres been an issue behind the scenes thats borked them (which I doubt because we have atleast one confirmed case outside of steve) or the generation chance is very very small in which case I think it really needs to be higher as even invaders are more common than swarm.

If I were you I would create a bug report and link this thread in that post.

Otherwise I'd like to add my voice to the "never found naturally spawning swarm" group.
Title: Re: What is going on with swarm generation chance
Post by: nuclearslurpee on February 23, 2021, 08:26:20 PM
EDIT: I've looked always at the DBs and the swarm wasn't even there as a race listed.

Swarms and Rakhas both generate a separate race from each encounter, unlike Precursors and Invaders who are static races and thus appear in the DB from the beginning.

I suspect that the bugs in Rakhas code may have been influencing Swarm as well based on reports here, in which case the fix Steve made for 1.13 may have inadvertently corrected this.
Title: Re: What is going on with swarm generation chance
Post by: captainwolfer on February 23, 2021, 08:53:56 PM
I have encountered the Swarm in my current 1.12 game. in the course of the game, I have encountered two different swarms, plus another time in my previous 1.12 game.
Title: Re: What is going on with swarm generation chance
Post by: Droll on February 23, 2021, 09:09:38 PM
Does anyone here know the conditions under which a swarm can spawn? Seems like there are a few people who do find them.
Title: Re: What is going on with swarm generation chance
Post by: Black on February 24, 2021, 12:48:29 AM
This is surprising, because in my current game I encountered two Swarms (one big and one smaller) with arround 40 discovered systems (realstars) and in previous version I had some encounters as well.

Edit: I only play with real stars. So one possibility would be that there is some issue if you do not use real stars?
Title: Re: What is going on with swarm generation chance
Post by: Froggiest1982 on February 24, 2021, 01:17:14 AM
Edit: I only play with real stars. So one possibility would be that there is some issue if you do not use real stars?

Don't think so, I play only real stars too.

EDIT: I've literally never encountered them.
Title: Re: What is going on with swarm generation chance
Post by: Jorgen_CAB on February 24, 2021, 03:29:08 AM
Don't underestimate the power or random, that is all I say...  ;)
Title: Re: What is going on with swarm generation chance
Post by: Steve Walmsley on February 24, 2021, 04:46:37 AM
I am playing the current campaign without swarm because I have run into them too much :)

I have checked the generation a few times and it is fine. The swarm has a 1 in 30 chance of appearing when the required conditions are met.

1) No precursors or aether rifts generated in the system
2) At least one system body with a Swarm Mining Score of 4

The Swarm mining score for a system body is calculated as follows:

1) Total accessibility of minerals where the deposit is at least 1000 tons
2) Accessibility is counted as double if the deposit is 1m tons or more.
3) Accessibility is counted as 1.5x if the deposit is 100k to 1m tons.
3) Accessibility is counted as 1.25x if the deposit is 10k to 100k tons.
Title: Re: What is going on with swarm generation chance
Post by: SpaceMarine on February 24, 2021, 04:58:22 AM
This is good  to hear but steve would it be possible to implement a way to increase spoiler generation chance directly for the player as That wouls give a lot more choice as to how much they want each threat to be, I think outside of that swarm generation chance needs to be a little higher but thats because I have never once encountered them in a single game like many others, so a slide system or a way to specify the chance you want would make sure each individual player would get the experience with them in their campaign that they want.
Title: Re: What is going on with swarm generation chance
Post by: Zincat on February 24, 2021, 05:25:19 AM
Yes that would be really really good. Maybe the best would be a... multiplier? I think it would be pretty easy tocode for you Steve.

Say, if you have a spoiler race ticked on during generation, you have a small box near where you can put a multiplier. Say, from 0.1x to 10x. That way the generation code stays mostly the same, you just need to multiply the chance with the multiplier selected at game start.

I would simply love to be able to play, say, a game with 2x swarm generation chance and 10x chance precursor generation chance.
Title: Re: What is going on with swarm generation chance
Post by: chrislocke2000 on February 24, 2021, 05:49:39 AM
Yes it is a bit odd, I’ve never come across them either and have played quite a few games now.
Title: Re: What is going on with swarm generation chance
Post by: ZimRathbone on February 25, 2021, 07:38:08 PM
I just ran into them in my 1.12 campaign....and discovered Steves little surprise  Thanks for that Mr Walsmley I had quite a few anxious moments there!

Title: Re: What is going on with swarm generation chance
Post by: kilo on February 25, 2021, 11:20:03 PM
I was not fortunate enough to find them either. After surveying 150 of the 300 stars in my game, there was still no swarm to be found. I was even coming here and to youtube to see what it looked like and there is nothing out, which is great and annoying at the same time. I would love to see the nasty things Steve came up with.
Title: Re: What is going on with swarm generation chance
Post by: ExChairman on May 04, 2021, 01:10:19 PM
30 Mars2205 14:35:50

Sensor operator: James Parkinsson: SIR! Is this Planet P ??? We have thousends of Search Sensors activating...
Commander Tang Ok-Myung: Evasive maneuvers!!  :-X

30 Mars2205 14:35:55
Computer voice: ABANDOND SHIP! ABANDOND SHIP!!

Title: Re: What is going on with swarm generation chance
Post by: skoormit on May 04, 2021, 01:12:44 PM
30 Mars2205 14:35:50

Sensor operator: James Parkinsson: SIR! Is this Planet P ??? We have thousends of Search Sensors activating...
Commander Tang Ok-Myung: Evasive maneuvers!!  :-X

30 Mars2205 14:35:55
Computer voice: ABANDOND SHIP! ABANDOND SHIP!!

Oh boy. The 27 crew on those lifepods are in for an agonizing last 14 days of their lives.
Title: Re: What is going on with swarm generation chance
Post by: ExChairman on May 04, 2021, 01:17:25 PM
30 Mars2205 14:35:50

Sensor operator: James Parkinsson: SIR! Is this Planet P ??? We have thousends of Search Sensors activating...
Commander Tang Ok-Myung: Evasive maneuvers!!  :-X

30 Mars2205 14:35:55
Computer voice: ABANDOND SHIP! ABANDOND SHIP!!

Yea, but how the heck am I going to clear that vypers nest? Almost 11 000 hits... :o

I have to get a lot of research in beam fire range done...
Oh boy. The 27 crew on those lifepods are in for an agonizing last 14 days of their lives.
Title: Re: What is going on with swarm generation chance
Post by: ISN on May 23, 2021, 10:13:06 PM
Have people figured out what's going on with the swarm? I haven't run into them in any of the C# games I've played. I've been poking around the database a bit to try to figure out what's going on, but haven't had much luck. It seems like the swarms are being generated just fine, they just aren't being given any ships. According to the database there are two swarms in my current game, both in systems I've discovered, one of which was discovered over 30 years ago -- but still no ships. I tried using the Create Swarm button in one of my systems, but it was the same story: it added a swarm race in the database, but without any ships.
Title: Re: What is going on with swarm generation chance
Post by: ZimRathbone on May 24, 2021, 01:24:53 AM
I just got one, two jumps from homeworld that boarded my poor little unarmed and slow survey ship.  The crew is now Soylent Green :-(

Time to send in the Battleship scouts...
Title: Re: What is going on with swarm generation chance
Post by: Stormtrooper on May 24, 2021, 03:10:15 AM
Have people figured out what's going on with the swarm? I haven't run into them in any of the C# games I've played. I've been poking around the database a bit to try to figure out what's going on, but haven't had much luck. It seems like the swarms are being generated just fine, they just aren't being given any ships. According to the database there are two swarms in my current game, both in systems I've discovered, one of which was discovered over 30 years ago -- but still no ships. I tried using the Create Swarm button in one of my systems, but it was the same story: it added a swarm race in the database, but without any ships.

Had same issue in 1.12. When I tried to create swarm, I got an error message, but it appeared in the database just fine. Except it didn't have any ships. In 1.13 I didn't check whether it appears in db (I didn't save after attempting to create them), this time there's no error message but still nothing gets created. Unlike in 1.12, that was in db without any edits...

Would be glad if someone knew what the hell is going on. Because from what I heard apparently on a fresh install swarm generation works.
Title: Re: What is going on with swarm generation chance
Post by: Black on May 24, 2021, 08:35:13 AM
Had same issue in 1.12. When I tried to create swarm, I got an error message, but it appeared in the database just fine. Except it didn't have any ships. In 1.13 I didn't check whether it appears in db (I didn't save after attempting to create them), this time there's no error message but still nothing gets created. Unlike in 1.12, that was in db without any edits...

Would be glad if someone knew what the hell is going on. Because from what I heard apparently on a fresh install swarm generation works.

I tried to generate the swarm in my game and it worked correctly, unfortunately as Steve is on different incompatible version of the database, it will be most likely difficult to find out what is the issue.
Title: Re: What is going on with swarm generation chance
Post by: Silvarelion on May 24, 2021, 09:04:08 AM
I found the Swarm in my last game.  Well, it was more like they got generated with my grav surveyor, and didn't get discovered until they were through the JP one jump from Sol and starting to munch on my civilians.  Mars was bug food and I was still 6 months away from my first effective military ship, so that universe was abandoned to the bugs.
Title: Re: What is going on with swarm generation chance
Post by: Stormtrooper on May 24, 2021, 01:13:44 PM
Had same issue in 1.12. When I tried to create swarm, I got an error message, but it appeared in the database just fine. Except it didn't have any ships. In 1.13 I didn't check whether it appears in db (I didn't save after attempting to create them), this time there's no error message but still nothing gets created. Unlike in 1.12, that was in db without any edits...

Would be glad if someone knew what the hell is going on. Because from what I heard apparently on a fresh install swarm generation works.

I tried to generate the swarm in my game and it worked correctly, unfortunately as Steve is on different incompatible version of the database, it will be most likely difficult to find out what is the issue.

I know and it's unfortunate. One version, especially after some dB edits (npr purges in the holy name of performance...), I can understand, but a second version, this time tested without any edits or patches and the problem is still there and nobody is able to tell me what's going on, then that's worrying. I wonder if the bug is so deep that even my base 1.5 install is screwed or something, regardless of the patch I put on top of it.